Tips for booking a Fire Island Pines hotel

Cheapest month:July
Most expensive month:August
Average price in Fire Island Pines:$456/night
Absolute cheapest price found:$140/night
Cheapest day:Tuesday
Most expensive day:Monday
$248 - $816
Average price per night / 3-star hotel. Prices are not fixed and may vary with time.
$140 - $678
Average price per night / 3-star hotel. Prices are not fixed and may vary with time.

Where to stay in Fire Island Pines

About Fire Island Pines

Often referred to as America’s first gay-friendly town, Fire Island Pines is a charming hamlet on Fire Island. It’s on the doorstep of beautiful beaches and native scrub pine protected within the Fire Island National Seashore and boasts a legendary nightlife at its discos.

Spend your days strolling along the wooden boardwalks that meander around Fire Island Pines, with locals using pull toy wagons to transport their groceries and goods. On the western edge of the hamlet is Carrington House, an early-19th-century bungalow that was constructed for Frederick Marquet and was later purchased by the renowned theatre director Frank Carrington.

Walk east from Fire Island Pines to relax on Great South Beach or continue along the trail that leads to Barrett Beach Park. At the far western end of Fire Island is Robert Moses State Park and the black-and-white-striped Fire Island Lighthouse, which has been guiding vessels through the waters of Great South Bay since 1858.

Getting there

Fire Island Pines is around 2.5 hours’ drive from Manhattan and just under two hours from John F. Kennedy International Airport. Ferries are the main means of accessing the hamlet, which is best explored on foot.

Fire Island Pines travel FAQs

  • What are the best hotels in Fire Island Pines?

    Clegg's Hotel (7.2/10 from 28 reviews), Privately Owned Condo At The Seashore Condo-Hotel (10.0/10 from 20 reviews), and Renovated In 2019-Sleeps 12!! Can Be Split And Rented As A 3/2 Baths Sleeping 9 (9.2/10 from 13 reviews) are all highly rated places to stay in Fire Island Pines.

  • How much do hotels in Fire Island Pines cost?

    Searches in the last 72 hours suggest an average price of around $2,390/night is normal for a hotel in Fire Island Pines.

  • How much is a cheap hotel in Fire Island Pines?

    Prices for Fire Island Pines hotels have been found for as low as $650/night over the last 3 days.

  • How much is a hotel in Fire Island Pines tonight?

    Prices for a hotel in Fire Island Pines tonight are about $2,712 on average, but HotelsCombined users have found prices as low as $2,712 for tonight in the last 3 days.